Skip to content Skip to sidebar Skip to footer

Exhibitor Spotlight – India McEvoy-Chisholm Finds a Way

Justiz-ESH was rattled before she left the start box. The 11-year-old Brazilian Sport Horse mare is hot-tempered and anxious to begin with, and warming up next to cross-country start at this year’s Eventing Championships at Galway Downs had not helped. Her rider, India McEvoy-Chisholm, knew their cross-country effort “would not look good on paper.”

“She was wound up to start with, and we had an early pin (at fence #5). I knew if I kept going fast and took chances, it would probably scare her,” India says. “So instead, I set her up very carefully for each fence and that eats up a lot of time.”

Around the midway point, the mare settled and India could let her gallop at her preferred pace. “At the end, I was really able to ride her and she finished nicely. It was a learning experience and I’m proud of her.”

Leaderboards don’t tell that kind of story. By her own laughing admission, India “brought up the rear” in both of her divisions. Still, there’s no shame in Justiz’s 16th-place finish in her CCI3*-L debut, or in L’Angel of Poppes 24’s 12th place in the CCI2*-L.

India’s on-course decisions sound like those of a seasoned professional, but she’s an amateur. She’s also an emergency small animal veterinarian and, with her husband Eric Chisholm, the parent of a 4-year-old son. Any one of those roles adds significant challenges to eventing at the international level. India manages all of them while bringing two horses up the FEI levels.

Finding a Way

“When there’s something I want to do, I find a way to do it,” India says. “Even though it may not always be the conventional path.”

Raised in the Petaluma area by an equine veterinarian dad and a supportive supermom, India was horse crazy from early on. The family had a retired Shetland pony that she played around with, but she didn’t begin riding lessons until her teens. “My coach said I was the least talented but hardest working student she’d seen,” says India with a laugh. Her “horse obsession” extended to devouring any equestrian content she could find. Videos from Badminton and those featuring British Olympic eventer Mary King were favorites.

Tagging along on farm calls with her father, Paul McEvoy, India was introduced to eventing by one of his clients, Valorie Bertoli. “I was a very timid kid, and eventing pushed my comfort zone, but I just fell in love with it.”

With four kids in the family, there weren’t funds for a finished horse. There was, however, a “baby racehorse” in the family’s field, taken in lieu of payment for a vet bill. Seamus had been living there “as a pet” for a few years when India started getting serious about eventing.

“He was very typical, nervous, kind of hot off-the-track Thoroughbred, and also an incredibly genuine horse,” India says. “He was terrible at show jumping and dressage and I didn’t know what I was doing, but we wound up being really successful.” Their eight-year partnership included Developing Rider participation and competing at Advanced. India later passed Seamus to her younger sister, who campaigned him at the lower levels until he retired.

Help with costs during the Seamus years came from an uncle who sponsored athletes in mainstream sports. “I still have the handwritten, in-pencil, letter I wrote to him explaining what I’d done and what my goals were and would they be interested in sponsoring me?” she shares.

Once she met her uncle’s demands for budgets, goals and plans, the answer was yes, in the form of buying and supporting a horse for a set period. That horse was a 3-year-old Warmblood that India developed to Preliminary before he sustained a serious injury.

East Coast Education

India went East set on becoming a professional rider. Skipping college was not an option, per her immigrant parents, so she chose the University of Delaware, where she could study chemistry while working for Phillip Dutton, whom she calls an “incredible support to me.” She arrived with a head start, having found a charter high school that let her use college courses to start early on her undergraduate degree.

When Phillip left to compete in Europe, India went to work for Bruce Davidson. By then, she had “renegotiated” the sponsorship deal with her uncle, resulting in the purchase of Jumbo’s Jake, who had Training level experience. “I’d say about half the time I fell off him, and the other half we won,” India says of their early outings.

A Change of Course

In her early 20s, while working for Bruce, galloping racehorses and studying, India had an epiphany about riding professionally. “One day I realized this was not for me,” she recalls. “The only other job I could think of is what my dad did.” She applied to veterinary schools, submitting the applications from a Dunkin’ Donuts parking lot because it had the closest free internet.

Considering acceptance a long shot, she applied widely and was accepted widely. “I did well academically as an undergraduate, but I think it was mostly because I had so much experience with large animals.” Her eventing and racetrack work added to a childhood that included raising cattle and sheep and shadowing her dad at work.

The University of California Davis School of Veterinary Medicine was the one school that both accepted India and allowed her to defer enrollment for a year, so she could finish out her riding and competing in the East. She and Jumbo’s Jake were hitting their stride, with runs at the Fair Hill CCI3* in 2008 and 2009.

The absences required to compete at that level didn’t jibe with vet school, however, and another of Bruce Davidson’s protégés, James Alliston, took over the ride. James competed Jake successfully at the highest levels, while India campaigned a young horse, Mojo, up to Intermediate as she completed her degree. Three of James’ international rides, Jumbo’s Jake, Mojo and Parker, are now happily retired at the McEvoys’ farm in Petaluma.

Making It Work

India, Sam & Eric

Having watched her father be on call 24/7 as an equine veterinarian, India chose to treat small animals instead. She works three 12-hour shifts a week as an emergency vet at TruVet Specialty and Emergency Hospital in Petaluma. That leaves five days to ride during the three hours that her son, Sam, is in preschool.

Her husband Eric is a “helitack” captain who leads firefighting crews into wildfires and rescues by helicopter. “He knows how much I love what I do, he’s very supportive and he’s a big help with things like fixing the trailer.” Otherwise, he leaves the horses to her, sometimes checking in with, “OK, how many horses do we have now?”

India’s two competition horses live at Red Horse Ridge, the private Petaluma farm of Nikki Lloyd and fellow veterinarian Sue Buxton, where lots of turnout time complements excellent care. “They treat my horses like they are their own,” India says.

Coaching is a patchwork. “It would be really great to have coaching and someone on the sidelines, but it’s not realistic,” India shares. “Especially since having our son.”

James Alliston and his wife and training partner, Helen, are good friends and occasional coaches. “I go out there and watch everyone and talk to the Allistons. They are a great resource for me and I really couldn’t do this without them. I just sort of do the best I can with what I have. I feel like I’m very lucky to have horses at this level.

“My goal is to ride as beautifully as James and Helen,” she continues. “But I’m out there and I’m in the mix and it’s not too bad.”

Two Mares

India knew that Justiz-ESH, aka “Pippa,” would be a challenge when she bought the mare from Zach Brandt four years ago. “She tried to double barrel kick the vet during the vet check, and he asked me, ‘You know what you’re getting into, right?'”

Patience with the nervous and “incredibly strong” mare is paying off. The pair had a great outing in a very challenging CCI3*-S at The Event at Rebecca Farm in July and won Open Intermediate at Twin Rivers in September, starting with a 20.7 dressage score. Smoother CCI3*-L runs are the goal for 2027, in the West or possibly back East in the fall.

L’Angel of Poppes 24, aka “Lily,” also came from Zach Brandt. The imported mare competed up to Preliminary, but she never quite jelled with her previous young rider. One detail India missed was Lily’s height, 17 hands, and she was shocked when the mare came off the trailer a year ago. “All of my horses have been tiny mares and this one is super long, and tall. She’s huge and has been a bit difficult on the flat.”

That’s outweighed by an “incredible temperament,” India continues. “She’s so sweet and willing and has been so fun to ride.” That was especially true at the mid-November Ram Tap Horse Trials, where Lily debuted at and won Intermediate.

Growing up with a veterinarian father and her own education are great assets in managing her horses, India acknowledges. She’s also influenced by DVM friend Jim Myers of Gold Coast Equine. “I know my horses very well and I’m pretty cautious. I have two horses and if one is injured, that’s half of my riding.”

Making sure her horses enjoy their lives drives their management. Hacking out makes up about half of their regular exercise, and much of their dressage work happens there. Canter poles and jumps are often woven into gallop work. “I’m an amateur, and when I make mistakes, my horses have to love what they do so they can help me out.”

Loving what they do is something India and her horses share. It’s the magic that enables this inspiring working mom to have both horses and high level accomplishments with them in her life.

E’Zara, India’s longtime partner who recently stepped down in divisions with a young rider. PC: Atalya Boytner